Score: 5

"I didn't actually play it."

submission: Autumn War

date: November 16, 2006

I think it's poor for any game to not have a sound on/off button, but since it's your first game I might have been able to forgive you. But.

You have a loud music loop with no mute button playing on the preloader of a 4mb file. Seriously, that's such a bad idea. I'm not going to have been the only person who closed it before it loaded.

Score: 3

"a sad example of of all surface, no substance"

submission: DTZ World Cup Keepy Ups

date: June 26, 2006

Nice graphic will get you onto the front page of many a games site, but you have no idea about actual games design and how to make a good, playable game.

Score: 7

"A nice game"

submission: Turret Defense

date: March 30, 2006

I really enjoyed tower defence games in WC3, and this was cool. But considering how long it takes to get past a level and how easy it is to mess up and lose it would have been a really good idea to give people passwords to skip levels or at the least let us continue from the start of the level after we die.

Score: 5

"I didn't even bother playing the game."

submission: Gladicus-ZERO arenaCombat

date: March 17, 2006

If you have to put loud, obnoxious music in the preloader for a 3 mb download, stick in a sound on/off button.
It's not difficult.

Score: 7

"A good conversion... but"

submission: Ball OF Madness

date: March 9, 2006

A good conversion... but your depth sorting is buggy - when the ball falls it sometimes remains on top of the platforms.

Also you really, really need to stick in a sound on/off button.

Score: 5

"Such a shame"

submission: Dragon Wizard

date: January 20, 2006

You've spent so much effort on the graphics and look, but the gameplay is pretty woeful. I gave up halfway through the second level. No variation, no indication of progress, no danger.

And if it doesn't start to get good til a few levels in, remove the earlier levels. Your comments show you obviously agree that they're boring.

Score: 8

"Music wood have really improved it."

submission: Cubefield

date: January 11, 2006

It's a really nice game. Fast paced and responsive. I've gotta say that some music would have really improved it. I didn't have any mp3 on the PC I played it on, so I played it in silence and it felt incomplete. For people who don't want music you have the sound off button.

I would regard not having a sound-off button a crime (of which I have been guilty on occasions) but of the two having no sound at all is the greater defect.

Score: 7

"An amazing technical feat, but..."

submission: Turbo Spirit XT

date: November 16, 2005

If only you'd spent the same amount of time on the graphics and interface.

Score: 7

"It was pretty good"

submission: The GHOST (demo .2)

date: March 3, 2005

up to the point I just fell through a platform and died

Score: 8

"Probably better than the real video, but"

submission: "Stripped" - VHS

date: June 15, 2004

When I saw the girl from azumanga (Osaka?) I thought there was going to be some twisted shit here, what with the song title, but I was disappointed. Just some well drawn anime traces. The clarence and betsy short, on the other hand was hilarious. Klacid, I salute you.